Chicago’s Push to Protect Gig Workers Threatens Their Independence

By Americans for a Modern Economy

October 27, 2026

Companies have long relied on independent contractors to handle the last mile of delivery, the final step from the warehouse to a customer’s doorstep. Now, regulations proposed in cities such as Chicago and New York would limit or ban such arrangements by forcing companies to hire delivery drivers as traditional employees. But these proposals threaten to upend what many gig workers say they value most: their independence.

While supporters have framed these proposals as a rescue mission for independent contractors, they ignore survey after survey showing what gig workers say they actually want.

A national Morning Consult survey of app-based workers, for instance, found 77% support keeping their current classification as independent contractors, while 85% say app-based platforms have been fair to their scheduling flexibility. Similar polling in Colorado found 77% of drivers would rather be independent contractors than employees and 91% said they’d stop working for these platforms entirely if they lost that flexibility.

For many workers, that flexibility is the entire point of the gig economy. As independent contractors, parents are able to balance childcare duties, students can avoid missing classes and retirees have the freedom to work on their own terms. Rigid, more traditional employment models strip away the autonomy that drew these workers to the gig economy in the first place.

What these local mandates also miss is how independent and traditional employment models work together to support consumers and the overall economy. In 2026 alone, 66.8 million packages are expected to be delivered, or 773 parcels per second. The last mile of delivery is considered the most expensive stage in the entire supply chain, accounting for 53% of total shipping costs. Due to time sensitivity and variables such as traffic conditions, geography and weather, it is also considered the most complex.

Independent contractors are uniquely positioned to help businesses meet these last-mile challenges. It’s a workforce with schedule flexibility that allows drivers to operate as needed, accepting and completing delivery jobs through a platform on their smartphone, all while using their own private vehicles.

Not only do the proposals in Chicago and New York threaten to disrupt this system, but regulating gig work city by city can create bigger problems. Delivery routes do not stop at municipal borders; a driver can cross through several jurisdictions in a single shift. This could potentially create a compliance nightmare that makes it harder for platforms to offer drivers any meaningful support at all.

And while supporters of these regulations are responding to real concerns, neither approach asks independent workers about the changes they actually want. And when asked, these workers consistently point to two things: practical business support and benefits that travel with them.

That could mean access to discounted fuel, safety gear or free tax software — the everyday tools of running a small business. But under current labor law, a platform that offers these perks risks a misclassification lawsuit for providing the tools of the trade. The law effectively punishes companies for trying to help. Workers also want portable benefits: contributions toward healthcare, disability coverage or retirement that follow them from platform to platform, without requiring them to give up independent status.

The city-level reclassification bills in Chicago and New York solve none of this. They just remove the flexibility workers say they value most.

This is where states play must play a bigger role in supporting independent contractors and gig workers.

States have the ability to build broader frameworks that protect worker flexibility while clearing the way for platforms to offer business supports and portable benefit contributions, without triggering employment status fights.

That approach replaces a potentially confusing city-by-city patchwork with one consistent standard and it actually responds to what workers have been saying for years: Keep the independence and add the safety net.